It Turns Out that Christian Attitudes to the Environment are Not So Christian


In 1967 a history professor from the University of California delivered a paper in which he argued the world’s environmental degradation had its roots in the Judeo-Christian notion of dominion. When the biblical text declared that humankind was to “rule” and “subdue” the earth it was mandating a view that creation exists to serve our interests.

Lyn White was surely correct that this was the way most theologians interpreted the text, but in Living with Other Creatures, Richard Baulkham points out that this interpretation owes more to Aristotle than Jesus. Aristotle and many after him imagined the universe as a great chain of being, with the gods at the top, humankind below them, animals below humans, and plants below animals. Each part existed to serve those above it. Early Christian theologians were schooled in Greek philosophy, accepted the Aristotelian paradigm, and used it as the lens by which they read the bible.

But this lens is not the lens of the biblical story. In the biblical tradition leadership is focused on service. In the book of Proverbs, for example, a king by the name Lemuel is advised against using his power self indulgently. His responsibility is rather to secure the rights of his most vulnerable subjects (proverbs 31.1-9). Similarly, the prophet Jeremiah castigated king Shallum for his self-aggrandising ways, when he could have served the interests of the poor like his father Josiah did. Then there is Jesus who taught that leadership is about serving rather than being served.

Read Genesis 1 through this lens and the mandate to rule and subdue is not a call to be served by the creation and the nonhuman animals, but to serve them. It is God’s world and our responsibility is to ensure it flourishes.

So I reckon it’s time to say goodbye to the Aristotelian paradigm and embrace the biblical.

Leave a Reply

13 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
11 Comment authors
Tania HarrisDick ClarkeKaren LeeAndy CollerHeather Healey Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
James Clarke

James Clarke liked this on Facebook.

Philip Zylstra


Grace Lanham

Scott Lanham an interesting read for you xx

Grace Lanham

Grace Lanham liked this on Facebook.

Philip Zylstra

Philip Zylstra liked this on Facebook.

Benton Wecker

Benton Wecker liked this on Facebook.

Richard Morrison

Scott. Have you read Schaeffer’s Polution and the Death of Man? It is his response to White!

Meralyn Zimmer

Meralyn Zimmer liked this on Facebook.

Heather Healey

Heather Healey liked this on Facebook.

Andy Coller

Andy Coller liked this on Facebook.

Karen Lee

Karen Lee liked this on Facebook.

Dick Clarke
Dick Clarke

Thanks Scott – too right!

Tania Harris

Amen to that!

By Scott

Never miss a post

Subscribers receive an email once a week alerting them of new posts

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest