Sheer Cold-Hearted Bastardry. History is tragically repeating itself.

S

On 13 May 1939, 937 German Jews boarded a cruise liner, the SS St Louis, in a desperate bid to escape Nazi Germany. They had visas to enter Cuba, and from there hoped to gain entry to the US. When they arrived in Cuba 14 days later those hopes were dashed. The Cuban authorities refused them entry. For seven days the captain tried to convince the Cuban authorities to change their minds, but they would not.

So the St Louis set out for Florida, only to be refused entry to the US. Everyone was aware of their plight in Germany, but it seems people were afraid of the risk of opening up a floodgate of refugees.

There was nowhere to go but back to Europe. 298 passengers went to Great Britain; 191 to the Netherlands; 214 to Belgium; and 224 to France. As a number of these countries were overrun by the Nazis many of the passengers of the St Louis found themselves locked up in concentration camps where 254 of them died.

After the war it was the memory of high-profile cases such as this that helped create the determination to do better, and so the Refugee Convention was born. It would guarantee the case of the St Louis would never be repeated, that those fleeing persecution would always find somewhere to go.

Yet 50 years on from the ratification of the Convention we are seeing history repeat itself. Australia became the first industrialised nation to turn boats around, and it seems that others are now looking to follow suit. We like to tell ourselves that Australia is only a nation of a small population and not significant on the world stage. But our treatment of asylum seekers has been noted, and as others follow our lead the international protection system will collapse.

This past week we have seen boatloads of Rohingya fleeing persecution in Burma hoping to find refuge in a neighbouring state. Thailand, Malaysia, and Indonesia have refused them entry, and standing by applauding this has been our Prime Minister who manages to completely invert the meaning of words when he declares that it is the only compassionate thing to do. As a result thousands of people are stuck on boats with no water, no food, and no hope.

News today is that Malaysia and Indonesia might agree to take the refugees if the international community guarantees to find them places to resettle. As one of the most affluent nations on the planet, one might have thought Australia would put up our hands to be part of this.

In hindsight the actions of Cuba and the United States towards the refugees on the St Louis were unforgivable. Sheer coldhearted bastardry. In years to come the same will be said of our treatment of asylum seekers.

Leave a Reply

39 Comments on "Sheer Cold-Hearted Bastardry. History is tragically repeating itself."

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Paul Banjo Fairlie
Guest

Paul Banjo Fairlie liked this on Facebook.

Salome Nel
Guest

Salome Nel liked this on Facebook.

Dave Rowe
Guest

Dave Rowe liked this on Facebook.

Sarah Gregory
Guest

Sarah Gregory liked this on Facebook.

Lisa Byrnes
Guest

Lisa Byrnes liked this on Facebook.

Ray Zimmer
Guest

Ray Zimmer liked this on Facebook.

Pip Berglund
Guest

Pip Berglund liked this on Facebook.

Wendy Creamer
Guest

Wendy Creamer liked this on Facebook.

Rebecca Roberts
Guest

Rebecca Roberts liked this on Facebook.

Emily Roy
Guest

Emily Roy liked this on Facebook.

Simon Cowling
Guest

Simon Cowling liked this on Facebook.

Leo Zubevich
Guest

Leo Zubevich liked this on Facebook.

John Silversides
Guest

John Silversides liked this on Facebook.

Nunes Di
Guest

Nunes Di liked this on Facebook.

Nerissa Prangnell
Guest

Nerissa Prangnell liked this on Facebook.

Michelle Terry
Guest

Michelle Terry liked this on Facebook.

Claire Suzanne Simpson-Smith
Guest

Claire Suzanne Simpson-Smith liked this on Facebook.

Susan Clarke
Guest

Susan Clarke liked this on Facebook.

Meralyn Zimmer
Guest

Meralyn Zimmer liked this on Facebook.

George Hayward
Guest

George Hayward liked this on Facebook.

Jessica Clark
Guest

Jessica Clark liked this on Facebook.

Barry Higgins
Guest

Barry Higgins liked this on Facebook.

Robert Cunningham
Guest

Robert Cunningham liked this on Facebook.

Scott Pilgrim
Guest

Scott Pilgrim liked this on Facebook.

Grace Lanham
Guest

Grace Lanham liked this on Facebook.

Vikki Howorth
Guest

Vikki Howorth liked this on Facebook.

Hazel Shute
Guest

Hazel Shute liked this on Facebook.

Shona Adams Sim
Guest

Shona Adams Sim liked this on Facebook.

Lara Harle
Guest

Lara Harle liked this on Facebook.

Kim Burwood
Guest

Kim Burwood liked this on Facebook.

Lyn Davey
Guest

Lyn Davey liked this on Facebook.

Martin Shields
Guest

Martin Shields liked this on Facebook.

Sylvia Jones
Guest

Sylvia Jones liked this on Facebook.

Felicity Wever
Guest

Felicity Wever liked this on Facebook.

Sunita Norman
Guest

Sunita Norman liked this on Facebook.

Barbara Higgins
Guest

Barbara Higgins liked this on Facebook.

Valerie May
Guest

Valerie May liked this on Facebook.

Annette Bartlett Davis
Guest

Annette Bartlett Davis liked this on Facebook.

Shelly McKewin
Guest

Shelly McKewin liked this on Facebook.

wpDiscuz
By Scott

Subscribe

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

Meta

Never miss a post

Join our mailing list to receive a weekly email with my latest blog posts

You have Successfully Subscribed!