Moral cowardice, moral courage and 1296 human beings in offshore detention


A few years ago I went to a workshop where we were invited to participate in a guided imagination exercise in which we imagined ourselves inside a bubble floating through time seeing what our lives would be like in 5 years, 10 years, 20 years. I engaged in that exercise this week, not imagining my own life in 5, 10, 20 years but imagining what life would be like for the 1296 people held in immigration detention on Nauru or Manus Island. The answer it would seem is that their lives will be exactly the same as they are now, for our government has absolutely no credible plan to resolve their situation.

The Guardian newspaper has released documents in the past two weeks that remind us again just how appalling conditions are in the detention centres. Those being held in these appalling conditions have committed no crime. They are rather, the innocent victims of governments that have committed horrendous crimes against them. The international convention to which we are a signatory permits them to seek asylum in Australia or any other country for that matter. Yet here they are locked up in conditions that we wouldn’t accept for prisons in our own country and with no idea when they might be released. And they have no idea because the government has no idea.

It’s not simply ineptitude on the part of the federal government. New Zealand offered to take 150 of the detainees but their offer was rejected because our government deemed it unacceptable to send these refugees to a place where they would be treated well. On the government’s logic this might mean that other refugees would be encouraged to take the journey to Australia. So it seems the only answer the government has for the release of those in offshore detention is to send them to places where their rights will be abused, where they will find themselves marginalised and living in extreme difficulty. Places like Cambodia. That’s it. That’s our government’s plan.

The government claims that this is the price we have to pay to prevent people drowning at sea. That’s a lie. What they should really say this is the price we have to pay in order to be free of increased flows of asylum seekers to our shores. It’s easy to prevent deaths at sea if you accept that will mean more people will want to find refuge in Australia. People only get on leaky boats because they have no other option. So we can give them an option. Assess their claims and then fly them to Australia. And while we’re in the process work towards a regional framework so that there is a sharing of the burden. Sure, it would be demanding and would almost certainly see many more people coming to our shores, but that’s the price you have to pay to be a morally courageous member of the international community.

Most Australians I know are decent people but we cannot hide behind that to somehow pretend that the policy we have on offshore detention is decent. It is not. It is a flagrant abuse of human beings that transgresses everything liberal democracies stand for. I just wonder how long it will be before we have either forgotten those in offshore detention or are so scandalised by it that we demand change. Because one thing is for sure. The current mob in power have absolutely no plan to resolve this outrage. It’s up to us to ensure that in 10 years time things don’t remain as they are.

Leave a Reply

15 Comments on "Moral cowardice, moral courage and 1296 human beings in offshore detention"

Notify of
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Rodney Holmes

Australia’s bipartisan refugee policy is cynical cowardice… it buys cheap votes thought the lie that detention is a deterrence. It does not save any lives while abusing & killing the innocents it locks up, it simply says, ‘go die elsewhere’ away from the eyes of voters, just like our secretive gulags.
Seeking asylum is legal; indefinite detention is not. Our immigration detention centres (& boat turn-backs) are cruel, illegal, expensive & unnecessary. There are legal, effective, affordable & compassionate alternatives.

Andrew Smith

Good comment Rodney, the key part is the buying votes part. It is such good political currency that even those who want to make change are unable to at the moment. A sad state of affairs when it is lives being played with.

Rodney Holmes

Rodney Holmes liked this on Facebook.

Lee Slinger

Lee Slinger liked this on Facebook.

Naomi Yorston

Naomi Yorston liked this on Facebook.


RT @scottjhiggins: Moral cowardice, moral courage and 1296 human beings in offshore detention:


RT @scottjhiggins: Moral cowardice, moral courage and 1296 human beings in offshore detention:

Astrid Elliman

This piece is great and so heartbreakingly true. If we’re suggesting a forward plan to prevent worse treatment in years to come it relates to policy and planning for regional solutions and I would like to understand what the major issue is. Is it conflict/poor relationship with Indonesia? UNHCR broken relationship with Australia. I’m not completely understanding the deeper issues with regional settlement.

Shona Adams Sim

Shona Adams Sim liked this on Facebook.

Lisa Byrnes

Lisa Byrnes liked this on Facebook.

Karen Lee

Karen Lee liked this on Facebook.

Jenny Bawden

Jenny Bawden liked this on Facebook.

George Nimbalker

George Nimbalker liked this on Facebook.

Thomas W Schmid

Thomas W Schmid liked this on Facebook.

Andris Heks
Spot on Scott. I once again enclose my review of CHASING ASYLUM doco. that takes a comprehensive look of the horrors of Manus and Nauru. AUSTRALIA’S AUSCHWITZ: NAURU AND MANUS ISLAND Andris Heks Is the above title exaggerated? Maybe not, after viewing CHASING ASYLUM, from Academy Award winner Australian documentary maker, Eva Orner. It is a must see for Howard, Turnbull, Abbott, Dutton, Morrison, J. Bishop and Rudd, every one of whom refused to be interviewed for this documentary. It is a film the Australian government does not want you to see. Just a small sample of facts from the… Read more »
By Scott


Recent Posts

Recent Comments


Never miss a post

Join our mailing list to receive a weekly email with my latest blog posts

You have Successfully Subscribed!