Australia. How we bludge off the rest of the world

I opened the Australian newspaper today to read a vigorous defence of the government’s  policy of turning back  boats filled with asylum seekers.  Australia has not only succeeded in stemming the flow of people coming by boat to Australia, we have apparently also reduced the flow of refugees into Indonesia, and saved people from drowning at sea.  This would be true if we could be confident that those who were seeking to come to Australia by boat instead opted to go somewhere safer.  Unfortunately, it appears that that is not the case.

The chart below shows the number of asylum applications lodged in industrialised countries since January 2013.  That is, it shows applications lodged by people who have shown up to a country whether by boat, plane, motor vehicle, or on foot, and sought asylum. The data is drawn from statistical tables provided by the United Nations High Commission on Refugees.

asylum applications

A number of things strike me as I look at the chart.

First, the number of people lodging asylum claims in Australia has declined substantially. This is partly because we’ve turned back boats ( i.e. people have sought to come and we have turned them away), partly because we deny those who do arrive the opportunity to claim asylum ( i.e. we detain them on Manus Island or Nauru and deny them the opportunity to apply for asylum in Australia),  and partly due to a decline in the number of boats  that set out from Indonesia.

Second,  our preoccupation with the threat presented by asylum seekers seems ridiculous when you look at the low numbers we have arriving relative to Europe, Canada and the USA.

Third,  the number of  people who have fled persecution in their homeland to seek asylum in an industrialised country is growing quite rapidly.  Moreover, for the  period covered by the chart the primary source of asylum seekers has been Syria, Iraq, and Afghanistan. This suggests that our policy has most likely not succeeded in preventing people from seeking asylum in another industrialised country, it’s just shifted the burden from us to Europe.  It is possible that the number of people seeking asylum would be  even higher  without Australia’s  deterrence policy, but I consider this highly unlikely.  Research suggests that those fleeing persecution rarely choose a destination beforehand, but go to those places suggested either by existing networks or migration agents/people smugglers*.  That is, the decision to flee is driven by “push” factors,  while “pull” factors  do appear to play a significant part in determining where people seek asylum.

Fourth, we could potentially justify this decision to push the burden onto Europe on the grounds that it’s a safer journey for asylum seekers to make. Unfortunately that doesn’t appear to be true either.  A report published earlier this year suggested that  since the year 2000 more than 22,000 people   drowned in the Mediterranean while seeking to flee to Europe**.

The inescapable conclusion seems to be that we’re a nation of asylum bludgers, that we’re quite happy to shirk the responsibilities both legal and moral that we have previously owned, and to let others shoulder our share of the burden.




Sometimes we don’t get to decide who comes to this country

This week Scott Morrison invoked John Howard’s famous dictum “We will decide who comes to this country and the manner in which they come.” We should decide whether to turn back boats filled with asylum seekers and we should decide who gets a visa granting them the right to enter and live in Australia. The…

The death of the wisdom of our youth

When I was growing up there were two pieces of wisdom frequently imparted to me: “the ends don’t justify the means” and “think about how you would feel if that were done to you”. These two pieces of ethical guidance were designed to help me act with clarity and correctness in difficult situations. The first piece…

That Strange Moment When A Stranger Offers Me Her Seat

It had to happen sometime. That moment when my physical impairment became sufficiently noticeable that complete strangers feel the need to offer me assistance. Last Sunday as my flight from Perth approached Sydney, a fifty-something woman across the aisle watched me struggle to put on the shoes I had earlier slipped off. When we landed…

A time to stand shoulder to shoulder with Australian Muslims

The great environmentalist David Suzuki has spoken of the shame he experienced when as a Canadian of Japanese descent, he and his family were incarcerated in their homeland during WWII. Being of Japanese heritage they were viewed with suspicion, so untrustworthy they had to be locked up. This experience was so damaging that Suzuki spent…

I have been blessed with Parkinsons.

In recent months my physical condition has deteriorated. The tremor in my right side is becoming more pronounced; I have found all kinds of things for which you need fine motor skills, like folding down the collar on your shirt, and bending down to put on your shoes and socks; I occasionally lose my balance;…

Is Marcus Borg a Christian?

Is Marcus Borg a Christian?

One of the most helpful books I’ve read in recent years is a short popular work by the Jesus scholar Marcus Borg. Titled Meeting Jesus Again for the First Time, Borg describes his shift away from the conservative faith of his childhood to a fresh engagement with Jesus. I found myself excited by the Jesus he…

A Prayer for the Middle East

A Prayer for the Middle East

Loving God, we know that both your tender compassion and your fierce anger are aroused by what is occurring today in Syria, Iraq, Israel, Gaza, and other parts of the world where people are wounded and displaced by political violence. Our hearts long for peace, that full-bodied peace pictured in the Scriptures in which warfare…

The New Bigotry

The New Bigotry

In recent weeks Facebook has been filled with anti-Muslim diatribes. They all share the conviction that there is only one form of Islam in the world, that it aims at the imposition of islamic law on all people, and is not afraid to resort to violence to achieve this objective. Anyone who is a committed…