A Better Way Forward on Refugees

A

Everyone can tell you what’s wrong with Australia’s current approach to asylum seekers and refugees, but what’s a better alternative? A Just Cause has released a document that outlines a better way forward. It shows that the world faces a refugee crisis. 17 million people have fled unimaginable persecution in their homeland and been recognised as refugees, but the international community is failing to provide them with the protection they need.

Refugees have three options for a durable future: first, they wait until it is safe to return home and voluntarily do so; second, they integrate into the life of the country that hosts them; third, they resettle in another country. Yet there simply aren’t enough of these options being made available to refugees. Protracted conflicts make it unsafe for almost all refugees to return home; the handful of mostly poorer countries playing host to 8 in every 10 refugees are not in a position to offer integration into their national life; and between them, the nations that have resettlement programmes, such as Australia, each year offer resettlement to less than 1% of the world refugee population. As a result, most refugees are left living a dangerous shadow existence in countries where their basic human rights are ignored. Unable to go home, refused the opportunity to integrate into their host nation, and with miniscule odds of being offered resettlement, they are stuck. TWo-thirds have been living like this for an average of more than 20 years. Others grow so desperate they risk incredibly dangerous journeys to places they hope to find protection.

The central challenge of refugee policy therefore is not to combat people smugglers, for this is to attack the symptom of the problem. Rather the international community needs to tackle the root problem, which is the vast gulf between the demand for protection and its supply. Quite simple, we need to provide refugees with durable solutions in a timely fashion.

Australia should therefore adopt short term, medium term and long term policy objectives. In the long term the international community needs to share the burden of protection rather than leaving it to a handful of poorer countries. This would see the international community working harder for peace so that more refugees can return home and agreeing to share responsibility to integrate/resettle in a timely fashion those unable to return home. In the medium term Australia should work towards an agreement among the main refugee source, transit and destination countries in our region to ensure that asylum seekers in our part of the world have their claims quickly assessed, are treated decently while this process takes place, and are offered the opportunity to integrate or resettle. Each nation would need to do its fair share in achieving this.

In the short term Australia should end its “Stop the Boats” policy for it does not address the gap between demand for protection and its supply. Consequently iy does not prevent deaths at sea, but pushes people to make dangerous trips to other places in the world. In a supply constrained world Australia must accept that flows of asylum seekers to industrialised nations are a reality. A possible way forward is to reach an agreement with Indonesia (as the main country through which refugees transit on their way to Australia) to jointly process asylum seekers in Indonesia and share responsibility for settling them. Increasing our refugee intake to 30,000-35,000 would afford us opportunity to do this and to increase our intake of refugees from other parts of the world. Australia’s geographic isolation makes it unlikely that a floodgate will be opened, and by providing pathways to protection people will have no incentive to board a leaky boat.

The paper and a 1 page summary can be downloaded at http://ajustcause.com.au/bordered-by-love/

Leave a Reply

34 Comments on "A Better Way Forward on Refugees"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Vikki Howorth
Guest

Great document – thanks for this Scott !

Matt Darvas
Guest

Thanks so much for this Scott Higgins. Have been waiting for something like this for a while. Can’t wait to give it a good read and then a good share!

Wildfiles8
Guest

RT @scottjhiggins: A Better Way Forward on Refugees: Everyone can tell you what’s wrong with Australia’s current approach … http://t.co/L…

Josh Marshall
Guest

And the other part to the solution is actually reduce conflict around the world. The West is guilty in taking actions to increase it.

Vikki Howorth
Guest

Vikki Howorth liked this on Facebook.

Brad Coath
Guest

Brad Coath liked this on Facebook.

Matt Darvas
Guest

Matt Darvas liked this on Facebook.

Salome Nel
Guest

Salome Nel liked this on Facebook.

Dan Beasy
Guest

Dan Beasy liked this on Facebook.

Craig Townsend
Guest

Craig Townsend liked this on Facebook.

Cath Taylor
Guest

Cath Taylor liked this on Facebook.

Benton Wecker
Guest

Benton Wecker liked this on Facebook.

Natalie Anne
Guest

Natalie Anne liked this on Facebook.

Brendan Wood
Guest

Brendan Wood liked this on Facebook.

Gershon Nimbalker
Guest

Gershon Nimbalker liked this on Facebook.

Hazel Shute
Guest

Hazel Shute liked this on Facebook.

Pip Berglund
Guest

Pip Berglund liked this on Facebook.

Tony Dawson
Guest

What a good idea, to focus on solving the problem! But surely a regional solution is the answer, like the 1980-95 strategy for handling the Vietnamese asylum seekers.

Scott Higgins
Guest

Hi Tony Dawson the doc indeed. Proposes a regional approach as a medium term policy goal but long term I think we need a new global approach

Ben Mckinnon
Guest

Ben Mckinnon liked this on Facebook.

Barbara Higgins
Guest

Barbara Higgins liked this on Facebook.

Christian Wright
Guest

Christian Wright liked this on Facebook.

Jane Alfred
Guest

Jane Alfred liked this on Facebook.

Susan Clarke
Guest

Susan Clarke liked this on Facebook.

Geff-Jeannie Gomez
Guest

Geff-Jeannie Gomez liked this on Facebook.

Ray Zimmer
Guest

Ray Zimmer liked this on Facebook.

Meralyn Zimmer
Guest

Meralyn Zimmer liked this on Facebook.

Ralph Reilly
Guest

Legend, Scott. Thanks!

Stephen McAlpine
Guest

I know in the midst of the Balkans conflict we took in Muslim refugees and it worked well. Some went home after, some stayed. After living in a large UK city for a while even though they did not let asylum seekers work, they at least let them live relatively normal lives in the city. Anything other than what we have, please!

Anne Hyde
Guest

Anne Hyde liked this on Facebook.

Ralph Reilly
Guest

Ralph Reilly liked this on Facebook.

Shelley Taylor
Guest

Absolutely!

Tony Dawson
Guest

Tony Dawson liked this on Facebook.

Bob Martyn
Guest

I agree with Vikki – Great article. Only got to read it now after reading your piece on “stopping the deaths”. I think its time now for more than words. I now know what I am doing – armed with your words. My federal member is about to get a visit – with your permission of course.

wpDiscuz
By Scott

Subscribe

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

Meta

Never miss a post

Join our mailing list to receive a weekly email with my latest blog posts

You have Successfully Subscribed!